Broker Check
Stress Tests: Putting Plans Through Their Paces

Stress Tests: Putting Plans Through Their Paces

January 05, 2024

KEY TAKEAWAYS:

  • Stress testing is a systematic way to evaluate whether the financial (and other) expertise you use likely will deliver the results you expect.
  • Eighty percent of single-family offices serving the Super Rich have done stress tests within the past five years.
  • Your own stress-testing efforts can be comprehensive or focused on just one or two aspects of your financial life.

You can do thorough wealth planning and implement a financial product, tool or strategy only to end up with unexpected and disappointing results.

Why? Perhaps something about the strategy you implemented changed. Or maybe a new law was passed that impacted its effectiveness. It’s also possible that something occurred in your own life that made your current strategy insufficient or less than ideal. Let’s face it: Life isn’t static—and new developments can sometimes mean existing solutions no longer cut the mustard.

The Super Rich—those people with a net worth of $500 million or more—are fully aware of this. What’s more, they often take steps aimed at avoiding being surprised by negative or undesirable results from their wealth planning.

The good news: You can do the same thing, even if your bottom line is far smaller. Here’s how.

Stress testing at single-family offices

Some of the Super Rich have single-family offices to engage the very best professionals to help manage their finances and address lifestyle concerns. Single-family offices are organizational entities dedicated to the financial (and often personal) well-being of very wealthy families.

A major reason for the single-family office is to ensure the family is getting the best results possible. Consequently, one objective is to work with the best of the best. These professionals can be employees of the single-family office or external experts engaged to address specific matters.

The complication: There are times when even single-family offices are not working with the best of the best. Sometimes they end up working with Pretenders—well-intentioned professionals who are just not as technically proficient as circumstances require. But sometimes mistakes and oversights happen even when the very best professionals are engaged.

So what do they do? To make sure they’re getting what they need and want in terms of expertise, services and solutions—and to determine whether those solutions remain on track to deliver expected results—the Super Rich and single-family offices engage in stress testing.

Stress testing is a systematic way to evaluate whether the financial (and other) expertise the family is using likely will deliver the results they expect and to ensure they are not missing any meaningful opportunities that could enhance their outcomes.

A popular approach

Stress testing generally is done because of anxiety about the current state of affairs. The Super Rich—as well as many other less-affluent families—might opt to stress test when they feel uncertain about their overall current financial or legal situation or about some particular aspect of their situation. By stress testing, a single-family office can help make certain that the family is indeed getting or employing the best solutions for their unique circumstances.

In a survey of 252 single-family office senior executives, about 80 percent of them engaged in stress testing within the past five years (see Exhibit 6). This demonstrates the pervasiveness of stress testing among even extremely wealthy families—who we find tend to employ some of the finest professionals available. Even they are strongly inclined to make sure everything works the way they want it to.

Important: You don’t have to be extremely worried that something is amiss with a strategy before you engage in a stress test. Stress testing can be valuable even when the probability of something being wrong with a solution is quite low. Say, for example, that a mistake or error involving a particular strategy you’ve implemented likely would be extremely harmful to your financial well-being. It might make sense to stress test that strategy just to be certain that you’re not headed for a disastrous result.

Two types of stress tests

It’s important to note that stress testing is not one approach. There are actually two types of tests: comprehensive and focused.

Comprehensive stress testing involves many aspects of a family’s financial and nonfinancial lives. For stress testing to be considered comprehensive, we believe three or more particular sets of services or products initiated within the same 18-month period should be assessed. In contrast, focused stress testing involves fewer than three sets of services or products initiated in the same 18-month period. Often just one aspect of an overall wealth plan is tested at a time.

Comprehensive stress testing is much more involved, time-consuming and costly than focused stress testing. In contrast, focused stress testing is more targeted (and thus less expensive and time-intensive).

As seen in Exhibit 7, focused stress testing is far and away the more common approach used by single-family offices. Generally speaking, only when the single-family office is experiencing a system failure of some kind—something dramatic that impacts many aspects of a family’s world—is it likely to undertake comprehensive stress testing.